Vertical Platform Lifts vs. Ramps: Accessing Your Home the Best Way

When it comes to improving accessibility in your home, two common solutions often come to mind: ramps and vertical platform lifts (VPLs). Both options provide safe and reliable ways to navigate height differences and access your home, but the choice depends on your specific needs, space constraints, and budget. Let’s explore the benefits and considerations of each solution to help you determine the best fit for your home.

Overview of Ramps and Vertical Platform Lifts (VPLs)

Ramps:

Ramps offer a sloped path that enables you to navigate height differences manually or with assistance. They’re a more straightforward and cost-effective option for smaller height changes. Key factors to consider include:

• Slope: A 1:12 ratio (1 foot of run for every 1 inch of height) is required.
• Landings: A 4' x 4' landing is needed for 90-degree turns, and a 5'x5' landing for 180-degree turns.
• Permits: Building permits are required for ramps exceeding 2 feet in height.
• Maintenance: Snow and debris removal are ongoing responsibilities, especially in colder climates.

Vertical Platform Lifts (VPLs):

VPLs are motorized devices that transport individuals, wheelchairs, and mobility aids vertically between different levels. They’re an excellent option for overcoming significant height differences without the space requirements of a ramp. Typical considerations for VPLs include:

• Landing Requirements: A 5' x 5' landing is required for safe entry and exit.
• Base Installation: A concrete pad beneath the lift ensures stability.
• Cost: VPLs are generally more expensive upfront.
• Maintenance: Periodic servicing is necessary to keep the lift in optimal condition.

Key Comparisons: Ramps vs. Vertical Platform Lifts

1. Cost Considerations:

For height differences up to approximately 24 inches, ramps are generally more cost-effective. However, as the height increases, the length and complexity of the ramp - and therefore, its cost - also rise, making a VPL a more practical investment for greater heights.

2. DIY Potential:

Ramps are easier to build as a DIY project or with the help of a handy friend. However, we strongly recommend seeking professional assistance to ensure the ramp’s structural integrity. Some wheelchairs and mobility aids can exceed 300 pounds, and a poorly constructed ramp may pose safety risks. With basic carpentry skills and the right materials, constructing a ramp can be a cost-saving approach when done correctly. VPL installation, on the other hand, requires professional setup to meet safety and building code requirements.

3. Maintenance Needs:

Both ramps and VPLs require maintenance. While ramps demand consistent upkeep such as surface cleaning, weatherproofing, and occasional repairs, VPLs need mechanical servicing to ensure optimal performance.

4. Ease of Use:

VPLs are more convenient to navigate, especially for individuals with limited upper body strength. With the push of a button, the lift does all the work, eliminating the physical effort required to wheel up a long ramp.

5. All-Weather Usage:

Ramps are typically located outdoors and exposed to weather conditions like rain, snow, and ice. In contrast, VPLs can be installed inside a garage, providing all-weather functionality and reducing exposure to the elements.

6. Space Efficiency:

When space is limited, VPLs are the superior choice. They take up significantly less room compared to a ramp, which needs a 12-foot length for every 1-foot rise, plus landings. Additionally, VPLs can often be resold or relocated with relative ease, offering long-term flexibility.

7. Aesthetic and Home Value:

Ramps, especially wooden ones, can sometimes clash with the aesthetics of a home and may reduce curb appeal. VPLs, while functional, can also be installed discreetly to maintain the visual integrity of your property.

Conclusion: Which Option is Best for You?

The choice between a ramp and a vertical platform lift ultimately depends on your home’s layout, your budget, and your specific needs. If you’re looking for a cost-effective solution for a smaller height difference, a ramp could be the way to go. However, if you’re working with limited space or require a solution that’s low-maintenance and easy to use, a VPL may be the ideal choice.

At Shift Accessibility Contractors, we understand that every home and situation is unique. Whether you’re considering a ramp or a VPL, we’re here to help you assess your options and choose the solution that best suits your needs. Contact us today for a consultation - we’d be happy to help make your home more accessible!

‍